Lightning Ridge"
50 ft Auxiliary Staysail Schooner
Concept Design for
Plywood, Cedar Composite or Aluminium.
Single hard chine, long shoal "Scheel" keel.
For Course(Interior Layouts)
YW Design Competition
Dimensions (imp):
On Deck 49.9 x 10,
At WLL 45.0 x 8.4 x 5.0
Min freeboard @ Datum +20 is 4.33 + rail 0.50
Displacement @ design WL ........25,600lbs (11.50 tons)
Canoe body displacement .......... 338.5 cubic feet (9.67t)
Total Below canoe Keel weight = 1.53 +3.8 = 5.53tons (47.5pct)
Shell area sans rub rail and deck = 700 sq. ft
Wet Area = 485 sq. ft (plain SA ratio =2.5)
Canoe body Draught 2.30.
Design Ideal Cruising Crew: Couple plus 3 other adults.
5-9 Berths: Port:Double-V Seaway: Dbl. & single Qberth, 2 Sea berths,
Seating can provide 2 full size transom berths.
2 heads, 2 showers.
Single Hard Chine with
bulkheads @ 1,7.5,12,15,21,25,30(full),37, 44(crash)
Rear overhang Datum to -2.2, front 45 to 47.7, total 49.9 ft
Bowsprit 7.3, LOA 57.2,
Performance.
All std indicators in high favourable range.
Hull speed 9.0kts
Brewer Motion Comfort 38
Full cruising load SA/D 22, D/WLL 125
Sails.
Spread = 55
Masts : 54 & 49 ASL
Light Air ...
...Jib 364, Main 488 & Genoa Staysail of 488 @ 133% = 1340.
Plain sail
..
...Jib 364, Main 488, Stsail jib furled to 368 i.e. 100% = 1220.
Very light air...Jib 364, Main 488, Fisherman Staysail of 832, total = 1684.
Heavy weather
(rudder balanced option)Main 244,fore 240, total = 484.
Total WR Main, furling Genoa, forejib on boom/bowsprit, Fisherman,
storm 80sq ft, heavy blade jib 240 sq. ft, interchangeable jib 364.
Main slab reefs to 366, 244.
Plain Sail C(effort) @ (x,y,z) = (24.3,21.6,0.0)
Centre Lateral Resistance @ (x,y,z) = (20.0,-2.3,0.0)
Steering lead = 9.6 %
Design Philosophy
This design takes advantage of the premise that if
you make sacrifices in one design element, in this case beam/accommodation space, you may
win more back in other areas. Simple in theory, this hasnt happened lately in
practice, requiring as it does a veering away from conventions which are not so well
established as people think. The theory that a 3:1 L:B is fastest only holds under
the racing rules that fostered it, rules I might add designed to limit yacht speed. Latest
Americas Cup racers are fining down to much higher ratios.
The fact remains that potential builders balk at any hint of
losing accommodation space, despite the tendency of modern yachts to be crammed with the
sorts of furniture designed for a comfortable Marina life. Stripped to the items useful on
passage, this Schooner retains ample space & comfort. This design DOES NOT ask
the 38 x 13 ft cruiser to lose any space, merely to rearrange the same area in a 50 x 10
format which is, lets face it, more the shape of objects designed to travel fast against
resistance. An aircraft or bullet train pushing against air is merely a high-speed
permutation of a the canoe body of a boat pushing more slowly against the denser medium of
water.
Unlike the old plank on edge boats this one has a low overall weight and
an almost planing hull with 18deg Vee sections flowing back to a slightly hollow rear run.
Its probably one of the few long keelers that could hold its own against the fin &
bulb cruising designs in one of the modern popular Offshore Passage Races like the Hobart,
Fastnet or TransPac. With its high ballast ratio and quite extreme WLL:Beam ratio of
5.4 this is a semi-displacement/semi-cutwater hull, with elements more in common with
early fast cruising motorboats than its more ample-bodied sailing sisters. It could be
expected to neither skim the waves like a modern racer, nor plunge extravagantly through
them like 20+ tons of traditional long-keeler. Lightning Ridge is designed to take
a middle line, capable of racing down a following sea without burying its bows at the
bottom, and cutting through the tops of steeper waves. The bow has massive foam-filled
flotation areas forrd of the crash bulkhead and below the V-berth, totaling over 80 cubic
ft or 25% of the vessels displacement. The pronounced flare of 77 deg. combined with
mid-freeboard & coaming heights slightly greater than "classics" of its type
keep the nose up & decks dry. Maximum beam (such as it is!) is carried slightly
aft, 20 feet from the rear WL datum. The hull is centred with C(disp) 2.4 ft forrd
of this, i.e. almost the WL mid-point. Overhangs are a mere 2.7(rear) and
2.2ft(bow).
Construction.
The ships narrowness allows light construction
without sacrificing strength. Accommodations lack nothing, but are weight minimized,
e.g. by use of storage bags rather than built-in lockers, cupboards & drawers. This
contributes to the ships unusually high power to weight based performance figures.
The necessary weight and longevity could easily be achieved using 20mm cedar
"speed strip" planking on sacrificial bulkheads/strongback. (if using this
technique instead of marine ply the hard chine would be replaced by a 1 ft radius chine).
Suggested layup is 400gram biaxial glass along keel & front "entry" panels,
followed by 2 layers of 600g triaxial finishing with a rail-to-rail layer of 200g
unidirectional. Interior of 2 layers of 600g triax gives an under 2 ton shell.
Low-placed tankage (beneath floors and at outer chine under seats/benches) gives nearly a
ton of effectively positioned water ballast (220 gals) in addition to the base lightship
ballast of 47.5% of 10 tons. Thus an 11ton cruising trim boat has up to 52% ballast
and C(Displ) almost 3 ft below its WLL. In addition the boat has a shoal draught of 5 feet
& a long 45ft WL, giving an easily reached hull speed of 9.0kts, and 200nm/day
capability. The idea of it planing with that long keel is pretty fanciful: a centreboard
racing version would do so running, or reaching if one could keep it upright.
Decks
The cockpit is simply a hole in the deck
surrounded by a 1ft minimum coaming/backrest: its sealed with a large drain. The seats
start at deck level behind the coachhouse but are six inches below at the stern. Seat
backs are integrated with the coaming so that there is sufficient backrest but the entire
below deck level (fillable) volume is very low. Access to the 50 hp sail drive is
from the lower bunk or head and there is sufficient space for cockpit access not to be
required. The forrd section of the cockpit floor is a 5 x 2ft panel of 20mm marine ply
bolted to the subframe on rubber seals -this can be raised for engine removal. A
sealing hatch provides access to the huge lazarette which in turn accesses the steering
gear and holds the self-steering and spare transom mountable rudder and tiller.
Side decks are 18ins wide and an 8 x 4 ft RIB sits between the deckhouses where it can
be easily launched at the point of lowest freeboard without any sailors being bowled by a
boom. Stanchions/rails are a matter of choice not necessity. There are two
Dorade vents per cabin. There is a manual winch at each rear corner of the two
deckhouses (4 in all), & all sheets/halyards are led to these. Loads are low for a
boat this length.
Accommodations
There is a minimum of 75ins HR under the 13 x 7
main and 7x 6 forrd 12mm marine ply deckhouses. The boat is divided in two by a
solid marine ply bulkhead at Datum =30ft. This creates two watertight ventilated living
spaces, which I call the "Great Cruising Room" and the smaller "Port
Office", the owners private stateroom and home of ships log and owners business
affairs or whatever computerized skulduggery used to maintain the modest flow of shekels
needed to stay afloat.
Both cabins are organized in the same way rear to front:
* Cockpit , thru sealing hatch down ladder to
* Wet Area to get rid of clothes, shower, forrd to
* Work area (galley, charts, desks) forrd to
* Dry warm resting area with no headroom needed.
Doghouse
Lightning Ridges low trunk profile
and open cockpit look great and minimize windage, but on passage would be apt to
alternately freeze and grill the crew. Cruising this boat at optimal speeds would soon
show the limiting factor to be crew endurance, & this would be vastly improved by
trading some of that elegant low profile for a spray dodger or better a full solid
shelter. The one drawn offers minimal impact on the base deck design; the only change
being the widening (to 3 feet) of the deck-level-seat aft of the main cabin where a
companionway is usually sited. This gives a step up to a sitting headroom doghouse with a
panoramic view of ordered decks and the confusion beyond! The house is only 5ft deck
length by 7ft wide, and could be removable for day sails/twilight races in warm climes.
Stepping in from the cockpit the house has a seat to port and the cabin hatch, now
hinged, forrd. Offset to stbd is the helm seat with the cabin top available to spread out
maps. Lines are led under the screen to cleats/winches in the usual positions @ deckhouse
corners. The helmsman can throw a loop over the wheel and use a narrow door to the
starboard side deck. It would be worth hanging a lockable rear door and hinging the
"chart table"/ trunk roof to make it a step into the MQB (Maxi Quarter Berth)
below. Furniture is minimized, e.g. the rear wall is correctly angled to form the helm
seat back.
Other Deck Structures
Low houses can be mahogany veneered before
epoxying for a very low cost. With a six in turtle curve matching the decks they are
strong enough to stand on and their height is disguised by the toe-rail of six inches
right round the boat.
"Great Cruising
Room"
Access is by hatch/ladder (no companion way) with
a huge wet clothes rack behind. The open plan theme also makes the boat seem much
larger - a snug double upper 3 8" wide and single lower form a "berth
box" in the starboard quarter which imitates the immigrant "bed-cabins" of
old, where whole families piled into curtained dive in cabin boxes about 5 wide by 3ft
high, with the (presumably six foot) long dimension athwartships. In tiers of two these
lined a great cabin either side; between was a long fore and aft table with transom
bench seating either side being used as a ladder to the upper sleeping tier. This whole
arrangement would account for the full beam of the ship, 20 feet or so, and the air would
be better on deck! All 4 sea bunks in Lightning Ridge including the upper MQB are
hinged at the ships side for level sleeping whilst traveling heeled. The huge
workroom can be screened from the saloon by a sliding flexible concertina door -these are
also used to good effect in the forrd stateroom. Galley is functional with the cook
able to wedge in firmly. Its large enough to stow food for a passage. position.
Charts space in the work area is a 5 foot table with mounting shelves/lockers behind
For electronics - a porthole/ 12v fan provides plenty of light and air... The 18 degree
deadrise enables a 4ft sole throughout living areas with just 8 inches of bilge largely
filled by the keel floor timbers. A comfortable dining table , with 4 upright
transom dining seats take up the centre of the non HR area under the mid-cockpit.
Aft of these are two comfortable armchairs each side with 7 foot snug quarter berths
curtained off at the sides and behind seating. It would take something extraordinary to
fall out of one of these sea bunks, and they are, along with the whole saloon, in a dry
area of minimal motion.
The Port Office
The front stateroom is completely sealed off by a
full bulkhead and only accessible by the usual deck hatch/ladder- this is the most
criticized aspect of the design. Reasons for doing it
1/ This is a safety element; the boat is already in two sealable
sections.
2/ The solid bulkhead provides the extra strength needed to design this
lightweight hull. For this aspect it is worth its weight in gold.
Q: Why not a sealing door? A. No one would ever shut it.
3/ A person living on or owning a boat like this is likely to have
business interests. The 5 foot computer desk and swivel chair provide a private, quiet
spot in a lockable cabin to take care of business without it impinging on the enjoyment of
guests or visa versa
4/ Both cabins have a head (with 2 x 2ft shower run by a hand
pump/bucket).
Wet & Dry
The problem of clambering into a small cabin wet
through is solved by the ladder landing you in the "wet hall" between head and
shower. You can divest wet clothes and hang them up before going through the
concertina-ing screen to the dry cabin proper. These heavy duty gray plastic
concertina screens run on tracks and are often seen in houses to screen dining rooms. They
are used as doors throughout this boat as they need no space to open, compressing to about
4 by 4 inches up one side of the door jamb, where they can be tied back.
The fore cabin is a perfect place to use them, on returning to the cabin there would be
2 in place between yourself and the head.
General.
This boat has no more material in it, or volume,
than a 37 foot cruiser of conventional beam. It simply stretches the envelope into a
faster yacht by maximizing waterline length at the expensive of beam. An offshoot of this
is that it measures under 9 feet from garboard to rail making it incredibly less awkward
to build. This fact alone translates to huge gains in both building time & strength.
Downside: an interior that is small for the boats length, but still extremely
comfortable. The biggest loss is outside the boat..Marina fees are often assessed by on
deck length. Buy a good anchor..the boat can be moored in six feet happily. If the area is
tidal a steel triangular frame just forrd of the rudder welded by hinges to each side of
the keel can be deployed as a hard stand in a receding tide, or as a stand for a bottom
clean. Water pressure once under way will fold the stand back to its flush stowed
position.
A theory on Costs
This boat can be built reasonably but is neither a
cheap or quick build. Its a serious boat presented as a concept design open to
research and finalisation to owners requirements and desires. Going as far as a Ketch rig
is too much, the boat design would lose its Schooner character, which I admit has strong
elements of an attempt to preserve the beauty of an Historic type craft which is very much
a part of Coastal lore. We should not stand idly by and allow the schooner to become
extinct. Building yourself or paying a welder mate I think you could get this done
for 100k including a durable sail set up. In the rig a compromise may lose you a knot but
she's a fast boat and that last knot is a very expensive one. I would be tempted to look
at Freedom style free standing masts perhaps stayed front and rear only. The great
thing is this -one can enjoy this build without constantly seeing very similar boats for
sale cheap and ready to go. There are very very few like it -Cheribuni 48 ,a lovely shoal
Staysail Schooner is the closest
it sold for $US 238,000 in 1981.
Conclusion
This boat looks sleek and will be swift, especially if care is taken in
planning trips to take advantage of prevailing winds, maximizing the running &
reaching conditions this type of yacht revels in. A family can cross oceans safely &
comfortably, but in the hands of experienced sailors other cruising ten tonners would not
see which way it went.
Jeff Gilbert Design
November 2000
|